Go Back   Natural Medicine Talk > Health > Vitamins & Supplements

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old 11-25-2007, 05:38 PM
Harry Hirsute's Avatar
Harry Hirsute Harry Hirsute is offline
Lecturer
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Propecia, CA
Posts: 1,840
Harry Hirsute will become famous soon enough
Default Vitamin E - Food Source vs. Supplements

Quote:
Vitamin E: Food vs Supplements



Here is an illustration of the apparent contradiction between whether food sources of vitamin E are better to prevent prostate cancer than supplemental vitamin E sources:

Two large studies, both published in the same technical journal at the same time, seem to reach contradictory results as to whether supplemental vitamin E is valuable in relation to prostate cancer. But are they both equal and contradictory? Actually, one is far more rigorous, and thus presumably more valid, than the other.

In the first one (Serum and Dietary Vitamin E in Relation to Prostate Cancer Risk <1>), definite and large benefits were shown for supplemental alpha-tocopherol vitamin E, but not for food sources (containing mostly gamma-tocopherol). In the second one (Supplemental and Dietary Vitamin E Intakes and Risk of Prostate Cancer in a Large Prospective Study <2>), only food sources containing gamma-tocopherol were effective, but not supplemental vitamin E as alpha-tocopherol.

A closer look reveals that the first study responsibly looked at serum levels and food plus supplemental vitamin E intake, then related that data to prostate cancer rates over up to 19 years afterward. This study's conclusion was that, "In summary, higher prediagnostic serum concentrations of alpha-tocopherol, but not dietary vitamin E, was associated with lower risk of developing prostate cancer, particularly advanced prostate cancer."

The second study looked only at questionnaires related to subjects' intake of vitamin E from food and supplements at the start of the 5-year study, then compared the number of cancers over a 5-year period to data obtained from that questionnaire.

The incubation period for cancers is estimated to be in the decades, rarely a period of 5 years or less. That, along with the lack of any data on serum antioxidant status and the use of a questionably reliable survey to determine intake of vitamin E from food or supplements, makes the second report far less meaningful than the first one.

Donít get me wrong, I am not against food sources of nutrients and routinely recommend vitamin E sources containing gamma-tocopherol, along with the full range of tocopherols and tocotrienols. But when preliminary or sketchy science is all-too-often reported as if itís definitive when itís really not, and when it is contradicted by better science, I am compelled to put things into a more realistic perspective.

The measurement of serum levels in the body, along with careful reporting of a nutrientís intake from various sources, is much more compelling than relying on a questionnaire that may be done by memory. It is well-known among nutritionists that daily food diaries are notoriously different than weekly food surveys done by memory recall, which almost always seem to conveniently forget the junk food, snacks and extra calories.

A cancer study lasting nearly 4 times as long is also far more compelling than a shorter one because it will be more likely to encompass the cancerís incubation period and allow for the development of symptoms that will allow detection. As the National Cancer Institute reports: ďProstate cancer often does not cause symptoms for many years.Ē <3>

...
http://honestnutrition.blogspot.com/
Reply With Quote
Reply

Tags
vitamin e
Please reply to this thread with any new information or opinions.

Thread Tools
Display Modes


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Vitamin D3 Supplements - Only Work If You Get Sunlight? limitme Vitamins & Supplements 22 09-20-2010 11:07 AM
Vitamin D supplements lack D D Bergy Vitamins & Supplements 10 06-18-2010 02:53 PM
Vitamin supplements are largely a waste of money, says professor jw8725 Vitamins & Supplements 0 09-10-2009 08:35 PM
Mushrooms, Vitamin D and More Food Facts Harry Hirsute Vitamins & Supplements 29 05-24-2009 10:06 PM
Food Sources of Vitamin K2 Harry Hirsute Vitamins & Supplements 1 11-09-2008 11:02 PM